Well, I thought about it, but you could never have granted my true wish.

5 seconds sound clip from the The Last Unicorn movie soundboard.

You can hear this line at 00:31:15.784 in the Blu-ray version of the movie.

Quote context

[...]

- No, I've never seen anyone like you. Not while I was awake, anyway.

- A butterfly told me of a Red Bull, who pushed all the other unicorns to the ends of the earth. And Mommy Fortuna spoke of a King Haggard.

- So I'm going where they are, to learn whatever they know.

- Take me with you, for luck, for laughs, for the unknown.

- You may come with me if you like, though I wish you'd asked for some other reward for having freed me.

- Well, I thought about it, but you could never have granted my true wish.

- No. I cannot turn you into something you are not. I cannot turn you into a true magician.

- That's all right, don't worry about it.

- I'm not.

- What do you know of King Haggard?

- I have heard that he's an old man who rules over barren country by the sea.

[...]