It would've been a Super Bowl ring, but Ray missed the kick.
5 seconds sound clip from the Ace Ventura: Pet Detective movie soundboard.
You can hear this line at 00:55:53 in the Blu-ray version of the movie.
Quote context
[...]
- You ever heard of a former Dolphin kicker named Ray Finkle?
- All right, VENTURA make it quick.
- I found a rare stone at the bottom of Snowflake's tank.
- It belongs to a Dolphin '84 AFC championship ring.
- It would've been a Super Bowl ring, but Ray missed the kick.
- Blames the whole thing on Marino.
- We're talking paranoid, delusional psychosis. I saw the guy's room.
- Cozy, if you're Hannibal Lecter.
- So how does Roger Podacter fit in?
- My guess is, Finkle was snooping around. Podacter recognized him. End of story.
[...]