Throwing' and catkin' and scooping' 'em up too fast and too much until a ball was hit his way that dropped from his hand when he tried to throw it.
11 seconds sound clip from the Destination Freedom - The Rhyme of the Ancient Dodger classic radio play.
You can hear this line at 00:17:29 in the radio play.
Quote context
[...]
- There's an overflow crowd. It means it's the politicians who're against us, not the people.
- This'll make quite a bit a difference, buddy, quite a bit.
- And the more they played, the more the difference began to count.
- But he can't throw it. He can't even lift it up. His arm swings around like its outta socket.
- They take him off the field. The coach looks him over.
- Let's see that arm. Oh. Pretty bad.
[...]